Grieving for the Innocent Lives
[1] I cried for a time, thinking about the horrible deaths of
all of the innocent people trapped in the World Trade Center, and
of the rescuers who gave their own lives to save others. But as I
cried I became increasingly angry, not only at the terrorists, but
also at the root cause of their actions. How would it come to pass
that the US could become so hated, not only among mass murderers,
but among thoughtful cosmopolitan academic and newspaper editors in
the Middle East, that many in post disaster interviews would see
this attack as a comeuppance, even while condemning the methods and
consequence?
[2] Thank God (or Gorbachev) that the cold war is over. But what
has the US done in its decade-plus unrivalled supremacy? Has it
tried to create a more just world order, or even thought
strategically about collective hegemony, or building new global
institutions that make people more secure? Much of the rest of the
world, not just the Middle East, sees unilateral arrogance, the
legacy of cold war interventions in nearly every major conflict
since 1945, continued one-sided support for the Israeli occupation
of Palestinian lands, and the abandonment by the US of six major
treaties (including one to control chemical weapons) since last
January. Just as most historians saw an unjust Versailles treaty as
contributing to the rise of Hitler, no one therefore blames France,
the US and Britain for the Holocaust or excuses Hitler and his
accomplices for their crimes. Nevertheless, that history presents
us with the counterfactual suggestion that a more just settlement,
less myopic policies, and a less selfish approach on the part of
the victors of the First World War could have made a
difference.