After more than a year of consultation and writing, the Committee on Appeals has completed a draft for the revision of Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline. The document has been reviewed by the Conference of Bishops, as required by the constitution, and now will be considered for possible approval by the Church Council at its April 2021 meeting. The document may be found here and the report from the Committee on Appeals concerning its work may be found here.
Revision of Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline
This church’s document Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline describes the grounds for which discipline may be imposed according to the practice of this church. Chapter 20 of the ELCA Constitution calls for this document, stating that “the Committee on Appeals shall establish definitions and guidelines, subject to approval by the Church Council, to enable clear and uniform application of the grounds for discipline of officers, rostered ministers, congregations, and members of congregations.” Its purpose is juridical: to assist in the processes of consultation, discipline and appeals. It does not set forth the high expectations this church has for all who participate in our life together.
It has been a number of years since Definitions and Guidelines was last substantively updated. The Committee on Appeals is conducting a review of this document with the intent to submit a revised version to the Church Council for approval in spring 2021. The committee is seeking input from across this church so the document can better provide clear and uniform application of the rules, protect people from harm and prevent impediments to the proclamation of the gospel.
Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline survey findings
In April 2020 the Committee on Appeals worked collaboratively with churchwide staff to design a research project to allow people across this church to provide feedback for a revision of Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline. An online survey was conducted across May and June, open to the entire church, alongside an invited sample of rostered ministers, bishops, synod vice presidents, and voting members of the 2019 Churchwide Assembly. A Spanish-language version of the survey was also made available. Efforts also were made to reach out to a number of constituencies within this church. A summary of the findings of this research can be found here. The Committee on Appeals will be using this information as part of their discernment in revising Definitions and Guidelines.
Revision Update: The Committee on Appeals is engaged in a revision process for Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline. A report on the committee's work can be found here.
Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline (existing)View Document
DEFINICIONES y PAUTAS para la DISCIPLINA (español)View Document
Definitions and Guidelines for Discipline survey findingsView Document
Committee on Appeals Report